5 Comments
User's avatar
Cubicle Farmer's avatar

One difference between the modes: a device that would cause minimal casualties on a train could bring a plane down.

Andrew Miller's avatar

There's some truth to this, though I don't think it changes the outcome of the analysis

Andrew Burleson's avatar

I think there’s also something to the lack of alternatives to air travel. If you’re going to fly from NY to LA, you’ll get there in 5-6 hours air time, plus 2-4 on either end. There’s no alternative that gets you there in the same day, so adding an hour delay of security theater may be wasteful but it doesn’t change your decision to fly, whereas for trains that delay would likely mean you drive instead.

Andrew Miller's avatar

Indeed... I make a similar argument in the second footnote

Andrew Burleson's avatar

Ah, didn’t see the footnote. Thanks!